Henry Westons Vintage Cider VS Lidl’s Woodgate Vintage Cider

If you’re partial to a Cider, or ever been a student, you’re probably familiar with Henry Westons Vintage Cider. This Cider was crafted by Westons Cider and they’re offering you a drink that I’d put into the category of “efficient” drinking – especially for those of you on a budget. To set the scene, I was browsing through Lidl’s [limited] selection of Cider the other day, trying to find a Cider to review. Parked next to each other were our close friend Henry Westons (Henry) and Lidl’s imitation, Woodgate Vintage Cider. Whilst Henry is already modestly priced in most stores, in Lidl it was an almost perfect £1.69 – LOL. Next door, Woodgate was laughing at a cracking £1.19. Woodgate, however, weighed in at 7.3% ABV, which looks pathetic when you’re up against Henry’s much loved, 8.2% ABV. But which one is worth drinking. Is the reduction of price a sacrifice in flavour? Is the reduction worth the less amount of alcohol? Well my friend, lets explore.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Henry Weston’s 8.2% ABV
  • Woodgate 7.3% ABV
  • Both golden hue
  • Both lightly sparkiling
  • Neither are groundbreaking 
  • Both have a strong alcohol flavour 
  • Woodgate feels more diluted
  • Both Vegan friendly
  • Both Gluten-free

Henry Weston’s

Because there’s a lot to get through, I’ll structure this post by individual reviews, then my final thoughts. 

 

What does Henry Weston’s look like?

Henry Westons has a classic look to it. If you asked someone to describe Cider, they’d probably give you a description similar to Henry’s.

It’s a lovely Golden colour. Like other Ciders I’ve reviewed, I liken it to a urine sample where you haven’t had a water since 9am and now it’s 7pm.

Henry’s is lightly sparkling with delicate bubbles floating up and gently sitting on the surface of the Golden Lake.

 

What does Henry Weston’s smell like?

Standard protocal dictates I shove my nose in and give it a good sniff.
And boy did I regret the big sniff I took.

The smell of ethanol choked me out. If I had some warning, it would have been fine and I’ve certainly smelt some worse Ciders.

As I take my, now prepared, second take, I’m reminded of festivals. 
Festivals, especially wet ones, are a fester of smells. Usually mud, body odour, terrible open-roof trough toilets and always Cider. Festivals are always memorable and usually pleasant to remember – almost nostalgic. This is how Henry Westons makes me feel. It’s an okay smell, it’s nothing groundbreaking, or nose-breaking (almost), but it’s nostalgic to me – and I like feeling nostalgic by the way.

As I lead the aroma down my nose hole once again, I’m met with apples, rather obviously. Not quite fresh, crisp apples, but perhaps older ones. Older in a good way. Mature apples that carry a few stories with them. 

 

What does Henry Weston’s taste like?

As most of us know, smell plays a big part in the overall flavour of what we eat and drink. The tasting experience of this Cider follows suit from the smell.

It’s quite a sharp, medium-dry start. You can definitely taste the alcohol in this one. This is followed by quite a pleasant fruity finish. It’s quite interesting. The Cider almost changes personality. It goes from being somthing that’ll put hairs on your chest, to something pretty juicy.

It’s definitely a clean, better second half to the palate and if I had any historical football (Soccer) knowledge, I’d use the help of a famous match to get this metaphor to across.

I’d also say it’s like an apple pie, but the apples are slightly aged. Not dirty or rotten apples, that would be an insult! But as previously mentioned, mature, well experience apples. 

Two wine glasses with Cider in them.
Henry (Left) Woodgate (Right)
 

 

Is Henry Weston’s Cider vegan friendly?

Yes, Henry Weston’s is a vegan friendly cider.

Is Henry Weston’s Cider gluten free?

Yes, Henry Weston’s vintage is gluten free.

Woodgate Vintage cider

For those of you who don’t like reading, don’t worry, the Woodgate section will be a lot shorter. This is because I was surprised at how relatively similar they are.

What does Woodgate Vintage Cider look like?

As you can see from the picture, the Ciders are pretty much identical. Henry is on the left, and Vintage on the right.
Both sit with a proud Golden hue. Vintage does however have less bubbles. So if you loves Bubbles, as much as Bubbles in Pixar’s 2003 Classic, Finding Nemo, then you’ll want Henry.

 

What does Woodgate cider smell like?

On the nose, Woodgate is more gentile, hosting a weaker smell of alcohol. Taking a big waft didn’t give me any shock value, or much value. 

 

What does Woodgate  cider taste like?

The mouth has a similar tale to the waft intake. Because it smelt less strong, it tasted less strong. 

It was way more watery. This made it drinkable, but for the wrong reasons. Don’t get me wrong, there was a traditional apple quality to the taste but it felt diluted. 

 

Is Woodgate Cider vegan friendly?

Yes, Woodgate Vintage Cider is a vegan friendly cider.

 

Is Woodgate Vintage Cider gluten free?

Woodgate vintage cider is gluten free!

 

Final Thoughts

To conclude, Henry Westons just feels like there’s more love and care put into it, and that’s what I had hoped. If Lidl, or any supermarket was able to pull off the exact same taste as Henry Westons, I would have been disappointed.

Henry Westons is an absolute classic. Yes, it’s not the nicest, or most complex Cider, but you know what you’re getting, you feel comforted and safe. For a Cider that’s under £2 a bottle, it’s a bargain. 
So Henry Westons may not be the King of all Ciders, but it is the Daddy of them. 

Woodgate, I salute you for trying, and for almost £1 a bottle, I’ll shake your hand. You gave it a good go and you know what, I’ll drink you again, I’m sure, but for now…I’m drinking Daddy.

 

If you love Cider as much as us, you can learn everything there is know about cider here in our Cider 101 guide.

Henry Weston’s

Eyes
Nose
Mouth

8.2/15

Woodgate Vintage

Eyes
Nose
Mouth

7.3/15

Join our FREE Community!

You might also enjoy

Love Cider?

We’ve got you covered.

Using our affiliate links to buy your cider, at amazing prices really helps our little blog out. We can thank you enough.

Join our Facebook Community!

Over 100 members!
Share your Cider reviews and experiences with like-minded Ciderheads.